Can the shale gas boom save Ohio?

By Steven Mufson,March 03, 2012
  • Darla Bruno of Canton, Ohio, was among the protesters at an anti-hydraulic fracturing demonstration last month in Steubenville, near the Pennsylvania border.
Darla Bruno of Canton, Ohio, was among the protesters at an anti-hydraulic… (Tony Dejak/AP )

The help-wanted sign is out in Canton, Ohio, for Chesapeake Energy.

The company that has led the charge in shale gas drilling is looking for truck drivers with licenses for hazardous materials, a purchasing coordinator for oil field equipment, a pipeline technician, a field safety coordinator, administrative assistants, troubleshooting electricians, a tax analyst and more.

Chesapeake is mobilizing for a massive drilling and development campaign in the state. The company has spent $2.2 billion and amassed about 800,000 acres of leases in the rich Utica shale that runs underneath eastern Ohio. It has eight rigs running and will have 20 poking holes in the ground around Election Day. It plans to install 200 miles of pipeline this year to bring its bounty to market.

“We are very excited about the Utica,” Chesapeake’s chief executive, Aubrey McClendon, said in a Feb. 22 conference call.

That’s welcome news in Canton, where the unemployment rate peaked at 12.3 percent in January 2010 and where it was still running at 8.7 percent at the end of last year.

But shale drilling has also presented Ohioans with a dilemma. Chesapeake Energy is using the controversial combination of hydraulic fracturing and improved horizontal drilling methods to unlock vast quantities of natural gas, gas liquids and crude oil, driving down gas prices to 10-year lows. That has raised hopes for a revival of industrial and power plant uses of the gas.

In some cases, however, companies that haven’t drilled properly have contaminated water aquifers. And “fracking,” which uses about 4.5 million gallons of water — about 1,300 tank trucks full — to initially stimulate a well and get it flowing, has raised concerns about the disposal of toxic drilling waste; a Youngstown, Ohio, disposal well for fracking waste has been linked by seismologists to earthquakes. In December, the governor ordered the closure of several disposal wells in the area.

A Quinnipiac University opinion poll in January showed that 85 percent of Ohio voters believed that natural gas drilling would create jobs, and that by a 64-to-29 percent margin they believed that the economic benefits of drilling for natural gas outweigh the environmental concerns.

At the same time, voters said by a 72-to-23 percent margin that hydraulic fracturing should be suspended until there are further studies about its impact. They said by a 43-to-16 percent margin that fracking would damage the environment.

Support for a moratorium was strong among all groups, Quinnipiac said.

“Ohio can’t have it both ways,” Thomas E. Stewart, executive vice president of the Ohio Oil and Gas Association, said in a statement after the poll was released. “A ban on hydraulic fracturing would result in increased energy costs and bring oil-and-gas-related capital investment and job growth in Ohio to a grinding halt, just as the positive effects of both are currently reviving once-struggling communities throughout the state.”

“They want the jobs, but they’re very risk-averse,” said Peter Brown, assistant director of the Quinnipiac polling institute.

For GOP presidential candidates stumping here before the Super Tuesday primaries, the issue poses a quandary, as it does for the state’s Republican Gov. John Kasich, whose approval ratings have been low.

“The politics of the situation would probably make a governor, even a free market advocate like Kasich, want to make sure he’s dotted all the i’s and crossed all his t’s when it comes to safety,” Brown said.

The latest boom

Oil and gas drilling is nothing new in Ohio. In 1860, just a year after the first commercial discovery of oil in Pennsylvania, drillers found oil in Ohio near Macksburg. By 2010, there had been 275,774 wells drilled in the state, putting it in fourth place nationwide.

John D. Rockefeller established the Standard Oil Co. by cornering the Ohio refinery business and pipelines in order to drive down crude oil prices and capture retail profits.

The size of Ohio’s reservoirs have paled next to the giants in Texas, California and Alaska. There was an Ohio oil rush in the 1890s, and the state’s production peaked in 1896. High oil and gas prices after the 1979 price shock triggered a new drilling rush, and natural gas production peaked in 1984, when high prices provided incentives for drillers.

Today there are 64,378 active wells, most of them “stripper” wells producing fewer than 10 barrels of oil a day or less than 60,000 cubic feet a day of natural gas.

Loading...

Comments