“They’ve used bully tactics, and they’re going way beyond the scope of promoting conservative ideology,” she said. “They are now trying to influence members of Congress through what I consider very threatening actions.”
Ellmers said she relied on Heritage Foundation research when she was first elected in 2010 but no longer: “To me, it is tainted.”
Heritage Action officials say the politicians who are complaining simply do not want to be held accountable for their conservative pledges.
“We understand that people are upset,” said Tim Chapman, the advocacy group’s chief operating officer. “This does hit them where it hurts.”
It’s not the first time Heritage has faced blowback from Republicans. The foundation was founded by Paul Weyrich and Edwin Feulner in 1973 to have a more aggressive presence on Capitol Hill than the conservative think tanks of the time. Since then, Heritage has weathered numerous clashes with GOP leaders unhappy with its policy pronouncements, including officials in the Reagan White House and both Bush administrations.
“This is not new: We get into battles with our friends,” said Phillip Truluck, the foundation’s longtime executive vice president.
The creation of Heritage Action in 2010 meant “some changes for us, no doubt about that,” he added. “But primarily, we are still and always going to be a research institution. The tail is not wagging the dog here.”
Heritage officials said the passage of the Affordable Care Act in 2010 crystallized the need to engage explicitly in political advocacy, which the foundation, as a 501(c)(3) charity, cannot do. (Some key components of the law, including an individual mandate to buy insurance, were once embraced by Heritage research; the group has since disavowed the idea.)
Heritage Action, a 501(c)(4) “social welfare” group, was seen as a way to harness the rising tea party movement and provide a vehicle for Heritage to press its arguments without having to register its analysts as lobbyists, according to current and former staffers.
The advocacy group quickly began issuing “key vote” pronouncements, scoring lawmakers and contacting voters in Republican districts. Hometown activists, dubbed sentinels, are tasked with raising the alarm when incumbents stray from what Heritage considers conservative orthodoxy.
Heritage Action jumped into the foreign policy arena Wednesday when it declared there was “not a vital U.S. interest at stake” in attacking Syria for its alleged use of chemical weapons. That stands in sharp contrast with recent statements from Heritage analysts, including several who called for urgent action on Syria last November and said the United States should “work closely with allies to accelerate the fall of the Assad regime.”
DeMint makes his mark
In its latest anti-Obamacare campaign, Heritage Action has coordinated closely with the Senate Conservatives Fund, a political action committee started by DeMint and run by one of his former advisers. The group is airing radio ads attacking Senate Republicans who do not support the defunding plan.
The arrival this year of DeMint as the foundation’s president — succeeding Feulner, who held the post for 36 years — accelerated a cultural shift within the institution, according to several former employees, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss the group’s inner workings.
The former South Carolina senator was a tea party leader who frequently clashed with his GOP colleagues. At Heritage, DeMint brought in a team of young acolytes who “were absolutely convinced that you were a sellout, and they wanted to do serious work to make sure we were ideologically centered,” said one former policy analyst.
Another former staffer who left for Capitol Hill said: “Heritage Action was sold to us as a small group that would give fire to the organization. Now, it’s taken over the entire foundation.”
The group has experienced a wave of departures to Capitol Hill and rival think tanks in recent months, losing its top statistician, its chief lobbyist, a senior tax analyst, a key retirement expert and a Latin America expert. Heritage Vice President Matthew Spalding announced last month that he was decamping for conservative Hillsdale College, where he will become vice president and dean of educational programs in Washington.
Truluck said that the think tank’s rate of turnover is consistent with past years and that DeMint fully supports independent analysis. “There has been no change in our policy direction,” he said. “Zero.”
Still, DeMint has clearly brought a new feistiness to the group. In Tennessee, he drew the largest cheers of the night when he declared that “the president just has a different set of beliefs about our country than we do.”
“I’m sure in his heart he believes he’s helping,” DeMint added, prompting boos and shouts of “No!”
“I’m trying to be nice, okay?” he responded.
“We don’t want nice!” a man shouted from the audience.
“Okay,” DeMint said, chuckling. “I know you don’t want nice.”
Montgomery reported from Washington. Alice Crites contributed to this report.